What The Employees Earn: Village Of Granville
Wed, 02/25/2009 - 15:14
 This is the first of a four-part series about the costs of employees in our four government entities: the Village, the Township, the Schools, and the Library. There has been concern recently over the size of raises for Granville Village workers, a four-year contract for the school superintendent, and upcoming negotiations on the teachers’ contract. The data in this series will help understand the reasons for pay raises, even in these troubled economic times.
The other stories in this series:
What The Employees Earn: Granville Township
What The Employees Earn: Granville Public Schools
What The Employees Earn: Granville Public Library
According to figures supplied by Clerk of Council, Mollie Prasher, the Village of Granville paid approximately $1,577,871 in total gross wages in 2008.
Prasher recently did a survey of salaries paid by nearby communities. Granville appears to be in the low to middle range of the group. For example, our police chief earns $59,280 while the range of salaries for the rest of the group is $59,571 to $97,418.
Note: In the tables below, when the Gross Pay is greater than the Base Annual Pay, it indicates the employee worked overtime. If the Gross Pay is less than the Base Annual Pay, the employee did not work a full year at the base pay rate.
Granville Administration
Name |
Title |
Hourly Base |
Base Annual Pay |
Gross Pay |
| Don Holycross |
Village Manager |
|
$91,800.00 |
$91,800.00 |
| Molly Roberts |
Asst Vm/Finance Director |
|
$70,747.00 |
$70,747.00 |
| Mollie Prasher |
Exec Sec/Clerk Of Council |
|
$42,656.00 |
$42,344.46 |
| Susan Hand |
Receptionist |
$13.99 |
$29,099.20 |
$29,073.28 |
| Roberta Stover |
Clerk Of Court |
$16.08 |
$33,446.40 |
$34,682.40 |
| Robert Wright |
Income Tax Commissioner |
|
$41,500.00 |
$29,209.43 |
| Alison Terry |
Planner |
|
$55,273.00 |
$55,273.00 |
| Alan Doan |
Janitor (p/t) |
$8.85 |
|
$5,361.40 |
| Robert Lavender |
Grounds Maintenance (p/t) |
$11.93 |
|
$16,316.85 |
| Michael Crites |
Law Director (p/t) |
|
$12,000.00 |
*$10,000.00 |
| Melanie Schott |
Zoning Clerk (p/t) |
$15.50 |
|
$7,647.01 |
| Total |
$392,454.83 |
|
* The Law Director was paid an extra $88,310 in 2008 for additional services. See a related story here.
Granville Police Department
Name |
Title |
Hourly Base |
Base Annual Pay |
Gross Pay |
| Jim Mason |
Police Chief |
|
$59,280.00 |
$59,280.00 |
| Dave Dudgeon |
Police Sergeant |
$24.76 |
$51,500.80 |
$55,874.81 |
| Keith Blackledge |
Police Sergeant |
$24.76 |
$51,500.80 |
$55,903.21 |
| Jonathan Dailey |
Police Officer |
$13.60 |
$28,288.00 |
$34,022.64 |
| Suzanna Dawson |
Police Officer |
$22.50 |
$46,800.00 |
$49,299.15 |
| Scott King |
Police Officer |
$19.14 |
$39,811.20 |
$43,494.74 |
| Zachary Markley |
Police Officer |
$13.60 |
$28,288.00 |
$32,421.21 |
| Jonathan Nicodem |
Police Officer |
$19.14 |
$39,811.20 |
$29,616.89 |
| Shawn Wilson |
Police Officer |
$20.13 |
$41,870.40 |
$47,256.71 |
| Justin Woodyard |
Police Officer |
$13.12 |
$27,289.60 |
$22,165.64 |
| Amy Strohl |
Dispatcher |
$12.45 |
$25,896.00 |
$27,391.08 |
| Deanna McMannis |
Dispatcher |
$15.02 |
$31,241.60 |
$32,240.71 |
| Justin Mann |
Dispatcher |
$11.04 |
$22,963.20 |
$11,246.50 |
| Matthew Carver |
p/t Dispatcher |
$10.88 |
|
$4,486.56 |
| Dottie Vaughn |
p/t Dispatcher |
$12.44 |
|
$18,913.85 |
| Benjamin Newman |
p/t Dispatcher |
$10.88 |
|
$7,602.85 |
| Brian Costa |
p/t Police Officer |
$18.17 |
|
$3,794.39 |
| Michael Kozanecki |
p/t Police Officer |
$18.41 |
|
$2,251.82 |
| Charles Marcum |
p/t Police Officer |
$18.17 |
|
$4,102.30 |
| Chase Rogers |
p/t Police Officer |
$13.00 |
|
$12,831.61 |
| Total |
$554,196.67 |
|
Granville Service Department
Name |
Title |
Hourly Base |
Base Annual Pay |
Gross Pay |
| Terry Hopkins |
Service Director |
|
$55,273.00 |
$55,273.00 |
| Darren Willey |
Service Supervisor |
|
$42,588.00 |
$42,588.00 |
| Jeff Bollenbacher |
Equipment Operator |
$12.50 |
$26,000.00 |
$26,518.59 |
| Carl Boysen |
Equipment Operator |
$18.05 |
$37,544.00 |
$39,064.61 |
| Michael Lowther |
Equipment Operator |
$16.14 |
$33,571.20 |
$34,295.20 |
| Rex Sines |
Equipment Operator |
$15.82 |
$32,905.60 |
$33,455.29 |
| Ralph Stevens |
Equipment Operator |
$18.05 |
$37,544.00 |
$42,848.94 |
| Randy Hays |
Mechanic |
$19.18 |
$39,894.40 |
$40,425.06 |
| Scott Cramer |
Tree Trimmer |
$19.18 |
$39,894.40 |
$40,071.57 |
| Aaron Chander |
p/t Seasonal Laborer |
$7.33 |
|
$8,134.70 |
| Kenneth Doup |
p/t Seasonal Laborer |
$7.89 |
|
$4,178.45 |
| Josh Groff |
Utility Plant Operator I |
$12.75 |
$26,520.00 |
$26,865.17 |
| Larway Roy |
Utility Plant Operator I |
$16.41 |
$34,132.80 |
$36,012.01 |
| Michael Root |
Water Distrib Op |
$18.00 |
$37,440.00 |
$18,720.00 |
| Erik Holmquist |
Utility Plant Supervisor |
|
$55,273.00 |
$57,398.88 |
| James Richards |
Utility Plant Op I (p/t) |
$20.00 |
|
$21,755.17 |
| Total |
$554,196.67 |
|
Granville Utilities
Name |
Title |
Hourly Base |
Base Annual Pay |
Gross Pay |
| Gerald Fruth |
Utility Plant Supervisor |
|
$55,273.00 |
$56,335.94 |
| Judy Gloshinski |
Account Clerk |
$14.75 |
$23,010.00 |
$7,168.50 |
| Doug Brim |
Util Plant Op II |
$18.20 |
$37,856.00 |
$40,110.70 |
| Total |
$264,366.37 |
|
The total gross pay for Granville Village for 2008 was $1,577,871.28. This number does not include the Village’s costs for Social Security and Medicare, health insurance, retirement benefits and other employee related expenses.
***
Bookmark/Search this post with:
|
I Hope Not...
I hope teacher salaries are not posted if others will be applying the type of simplified and uninformed analysis suggested by Interested Observer.
PS: This was intended to be posted below. Sorry, it’s a bit out of context sitting up here, as a new thread and by itself.
Apples To Apples
When comparing government salaries to those in the private sector, a conversion factor needs to be applied. When I was on Council, my recollection is that the “benefits” cost was about 25 percent of the salaries. The benefits included a very generous health insurance plan, a defined benefit retirement plan, sick leave, etc. Thus, when comparing salaries to those in the private sector, one needs to increase the government salaries appropriately by the value of the benefits.
In considering whether salaries are appropriate or not, the real test is whether we are getting the people we want and whether we are keeping those people. Rather than increasing salaries across the board, we probably should have looked at this selectively. For example, when I was on Council, there was some discussion that we would train our police officers, and when trained, the officers would leave for another community that had higher paying jobs. This would be an indication that we might have needed to increase certain salaries in the police department. Also, we have experienced a succession of Village Planners, and each time someone new comes in, they have to learn the history of WHY certain zoning ordinances are in place. Maybe, it would be worth paying more to keep the person we want in this position.
On the other hand, maybe some salaries were already in line, or even over paid. I question whether this sizable of an increase across the board was appropriate in this period of economic stagnation. In some areas, we are paying tens of thousands of dollars more than we were just a few years ago.
Job security should impact appropriate wage and salary levels
I agree.
The across the board increase makes no sense. There probably are some positions that are underpaid and those should have been increased. But the rest?
In addition to the good points Dan Bellman makes, I would add another important factor. Village employees do not face the risk of job loss that private sector employees face all the time. Those risks of job loss are particularly acute in times such as these. To not recognize that greater job security, and greater pension security, are relevant to the wage or salary paid indicates just plain bad management.
When deflation has hit the housing market and will potentially be spreading throughout the economy, to give 3% increases for each of the next three years is quite unwise. To do so when you are also giving step increases of similar percentages is malpractice.
Some of those PD employees
Some of those PD employees could probably qualify for welfare
Too many administrative postitions
Just curious
I am wondering what the salary is of Mr. Emery and Mr. Dilbone. These are fairly new postions recently created. What kind of value do these positions add to the school system, and what kind of payback do we as taxpayers expect to get for the cost of their salary.
I'm not an expert in the field, but the salaries seem reasonable
No ones’ hourly rate, gross pay or salary seemed out of line to me. You’ve got to pay well enough to keep good people in these important jobs.
Publishing teachers’ salaries seems a bit nosy, but as public employees we have a right to know. Arguments about teachers’ salaries will likely intensify as our economy declines. I do wish someone would figure out how to fairly compensate teachers for their performance in the classroom. Perhaps such a system exists, but I haven’t seen it.
good start
i hope you will publish all of the teacher’s salaries by name and provide their effective hourly rates … 180 days times 8 hours is an annual amount of 1,440 hours versus the standard of 40 hours per week for 52 weeks of 2,080 hours. A teacher making $60,000 is making $41.66 per hour plus a very rich benefit plan.
Interested Observer
good start
Voice of Reason
If you want to calculate teacher salaries, please don’t assume you know how many hours teachers work. Most teachers I know put in far more than eight hours for 180 days. They work nights, weekends, and during vacations. They put in time during the summer. When they’re not correcting, planning, attending student events, reading professional materials, and emailing parents, they’re agonizing over the student who is having difficulty or how to tweak a lesson plan to better reach each child. To try to come up with an hourly rate for someone in the teaching profession is ignorant.
unless you are on an
unless you are on an assembly line everyone works more than 8 hours a day today. the statement they work more than 1400 is really weak in today’s world.
Interested Observer
That's my point. You implied
That’s my point. You implied that teachers work on an assembly line and “earn” an hourly rate. Thanks for proving me right.